Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin Williams (Grades, Differences, & Costs)

Are you trying to figure out whether Benjamin Moore or Sherwin Williams has the better paint? When painting your home, you’ll want the best results. This probably has you wondering which brand of paint is the best. 

Both of these paint brands are the top choices of professionals because of the amazing results. Benjamin Moore has more paint options. You can choose from a variety of colors and many of the paints only require 1 coat. Sherwin Williams is available across more stores. Their paints have higher pigment and last longer than the competitors.

You have a lot of options when it comes to choosing paint for your home project. However, Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams are the experts’ choices for a quality paint job. Today, we’re going to compare these 2 best-selling paint brands to give you a better idea of which one you want to use for your next project.

A Comparison of Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams Paint

If you’re planning to paint an area in your home, choosing the right paint is important to get good results. Let’s take a look at the difference between Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams paint. 

Benjamin Moore Paint

Benjamin Moore is one of the biggest names in America for paint. This company was founded in Brooklyn, NY in 1883 and continues to supply some of the best paint and stains in the US. 

There are many reasons why people choose Benjamin Moore for their painting projects. To begin with, they have the best color selection. You have over 3,500 color options to choose from. 

So, why do all the experts choose Benjamin Moore paint? With the many choices from this brand, there’s one thing you can always expect, superior quality. The paints are low splatter and fade-resistant. They also blend very well, making touch-ups easier.

Benjamin Moore Paint

You don’t have to be a professional painter to get amazing results from Benjamin Moore paints. All of their paints are easy to use, so even if it’s your first time painting a wall, you’ll be impressed by the finished project.

Benjamin Moore paint is thick and has excellent coverage. Most projects will only need 1 or 2 coats of paint for a professional-looking finish. You can expect durable paints that are resistant to chipping and wear and tear when you choose this brand.   

The Grades of Benjamin Moore’s Paint

For the best results, you need to choose the right grade of paint for the surface you intend to paint. There are 4 grades of paint in Benjamin Moore’s collection, Ben, Regal, Aura, and Advance. Let’s take a look at what makes each of these paints unique.

Ben Grade by Benjamin Moore
  • Ben was the first grade of paint introduced by Benjamin Moore. If it’s your first time painting, this is a great option to consider because it’s very easy to work with. However, Ben is thinner than other paints from Benjamin Moore, so it will take 2 coats of paint. 
  • Regal is a mid-range grade paint and primer in one. This is an acrylic paint that’s perfect for high-traffic areas because it’s durable and washable. It’s a great choice for kitchens and bathrooms because it’s also mildew-resistant. 
  • Aura is a premium paint grade. This is usually the professionals’ top choice. The viscosity of the paint is extremely thick, which allows for high coverage. It’s also fade-resistant with UV protection. There’s an Aura Spa and Bath line for rooms with higher humidity.
  • Advance can be used for interior or exterior. It’s a top choice paint for doors, cabinets, trim, and other projects. This paint is easy to use and has excellent coverage There are several finishes to choose from, like satin, high-gloss, matte, and more.  
Aura Grade by Benjamin Moore

The Pricing of Benjamin Moore’s Paint

Benjamin Moore is considered a premium brand, so you can expect to pay a higher price. According to the brand’s official website, the prices of interior and exterior paint range from $46.99 to $98.99. However, most paints on the site work out to be $3.79 per liter. 

If you are planning out your budget, it’s important to include any other service you may need for your paint selection. Color swatches and bundles are available starting at $2.50 per swatch. You can also arrange a color consultation, which can cost between $40 and $80.

Want to know more about what to expect cost-wise? Let’s take a look at the price of some of Benjamin Moore’s best-selling paints.

Muresco Ceiling Paint$46.99
Ben Interior Paint$52.99
Ben Waterborne Exterior Paint$65.99
Regal Select Exterior Paint$82.99
Regal Select Waterborne Interior Paint$82.99
Aura Bath & Spa Waterborne Interior Paint$98.99

Benjamin Moore’s Paint- Pros & Cons

Easy to cleanExpensive
More color choices and color matchingFewer locations to buy Benjamin Moore paint
Fade-resistant Charges customers for color consultations
Durable and resistant to chipping

Sherwin Williams Paint

Sherwin Williams has been named as a global leader of paint and coating. If the professional you seek advice from doesn’t recommend Benjamin Moore, you can bet that Sherwin Williams is the name they suggest.

Since Sherwin Williams has more business relationships with retailers around the world, it’s easier to find their paints. You likely won’t have to do a lot of traveling to find a hardware store selling this brand.

This brand is a trusted name in paint because of the quality of the results. Each paint formula contains more pigment and binders than competitors. This leads to a denser coverage with more color. 

Sherwin Williams Paint

There are over 1,700 colors to choose from. However, it doesn’t end there. Sherwin Williams is able to color match. If you have a specific color you want for your project, this brand will be able to make it happen. 

Sherwin Williams also makes the process of choosing the right paint and color easier for their customers. At no extra charge, you can use online tools and paint calculators to help you make the right decision.

The Grades of Sherwin Williams’ Paint

You can expect premium quality paint no matter which Sherwin Williams paint you choose. However, for the best results, you will need to choose a specific paint grade. Sherwin Williams has 3 highly-recommended grades, Emerald, SuperPaint, and Duration

Emerald Grade by Sherwin Williams
  • Emerald is one of the longest-lasting Sherwin Williams formulas. Homeowners can expect 10 to 15 years from their paint job. This interior paint features stain-blocking technology, is mold and mildew-resistant, and has a tighter finish to prevent dust buildup.
  • SuperPaint is the easiest Sherwin Williams formula to work with. This is a budget-friendly paint that is made for interior surfaces. It’s a durable paint that’s resistant to scrubbing. 
  • Duration is known for its excellent coverage. Many people enjoy the finished results of this paint because it cures with a soft and thick film. This durable paint typically lasts 8 to 10 years.  
SuperPaint Grade by Sherwin Williams

The Pricing of Sherwin Williams’ Paint

Since Sherwin Williams is a premium paint brand, it will be costly. On the Sherwin Williams’ website, the interior paint ranges from $42.99 to $116.49 per gallon at regular price. Keep in mind, the price of this paint may vary depending on the hardware store you purchase it from.

One of the things that people prefer about Sherwin Williams when compared to Benjamin Moore is that they don’t charge for help. You will be able to use all of the color consultation services to pick the right shade without having to pay any extra fees. 

Are you interested in learning more about the cost of Sherwin Williams’ paint? Let’s take a look at the cost of some of the best-selling products.

Eminence High-Performance Ceiling Paint$42.49 per gallon
SuperPaint Interior Latex (With Sanitizing Technology)$77.99 per gallon
Porch and Floor Enamel$80.49 per gallon
All Surface Enamel Latex$83.99 per gallon
Scuff Tuff Interior Waterbase Enamel$100.39 to $102.39 per gallon
Emerald Designer Edition Interior Latex Paint$109.49 to $116.49 per gallon

Sherwin Williams’ Pant- Pros & Cons

Wider availabilityExpensive
Durable and long-lastingFewer options than Benjamin Moore
Higher pigmentation
Easy to clean


Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams are pretty even when it comes to quality and pricing. With Benjamin Moore, you will receive more color and paint options to choose from.

There are more paint grades to choose from, making it easier to find paint for specific projects. While there are some extra costs involved, the finished product is always worth it.

Sherwin Williams is a great choice because it’s one premium paint brand that you can find nearly anywhere. This brand is known for consistently good quality and amazing colors. Since the company uses extra pigmentation, you can expect bright colors that last for many years.

Leave a Comment